Monday 22 January 2018

More on Submissions to the Koshyari Committee including Army Rep presentation




            Please note: - The total number of pages in the Report is 90. Only 19 pages are in the public domain. The complete Report with who said what is awaited.


Annexure – I

(of the Koshyari Committee Report)



LIST OF REPRESENTATIVES OF NGOs AND INDIVIDUALS WHO APPEARED BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON PETITIONS PRAYING FOR GRANT OF ONE RANK ONE PENSION TO THE ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL



I           Indian Ex-Services League, Chanakyapuri, Delhi



1.        Brig R K S Gulia, President

2.        Brig Kartar Singh, Rajasthan State Ex-Services League

3.        AVM R P Mishra, Vice President

4.        Commander B B Sharma (retd)



II          All India Ex-Services Welfare Association, R K Puram, New Delhi



1.        Lt Col Inderjit Singh (retd)

2.        Brig Bhagwan Singh (retd)

3.        Capt U R Nikam (retd)

4.        Lt Nar Singh Dass (retd)

5.        Capt Bhagwan Dass (retd)

6.        Sub Mange Ram (retd)    



III        Retired Defence Officers Association (Regd) Dwarka, Delhi



1.        Lt Col B K Sharma (retd)

2.        Lt Col Satwant Singh



IV        All-India Ex-Para Military Personnel Association, Dehradun, Uttarakhand



1.        Shri S S Kothiyal IG (retd)

2.        Ahri A Alur IG (retd)

3.        Shril M L Verma IG (retd)

4.        Shri H G Garg IG (retd)



V         Dehradun Ex-Services League, Dehradun



1.        Brigadier K G Behl (retd) President

2.        Brig R S Rawat (retd)        

3.        Col M M P Kala (retd)



VI        Indian Ex-Servicemen Movement, Gurgaon



1.        Maj Gen Satbir Singh (retd)

2.        Lt Gen R S Kadyan, Chairman, IESM

3.        Col R P Chaturvedi

4.        Sub Mah (Hony Lt) Kameshwar Pandey



VII       All India Central Confederation of Pensioners Association, Patparganj, Delhi



1.        Shri S S Ramachandran, Gen Secy

2.        Col P K Singh



VIII      Individual Representatives



1.        Vice  Admiral Harinder Singh (retd) PVSM, AVSM, Noida

2.        Rear Admiral Arun Saxena (retd) AVSM, VSM, Gurgaon

3.        Brigadier V Mahalingan (retd) Noida



ANNEXURE – II



FOCAL POINTS ON THE PRESENTATION MADE BY REPRESENTATIVES OF INDIAN ARMY ON 27TH MAY 2011



SLIDE 1



TITLE:                         OROP



·        IN MILITARY, EQUALITY IN SERVICE HAS TWO COMPONENTS



Ø     RANK

Ø     LENGTH OF SERVICE



·        HENCE TWO MILITARY PERSONS IN SAME RANK AND EQUAL LENGTH OF SERVICE SHOULD GET SAME PENSION IRRESPECTIVE OF DATE OF RETIREMENT



SLIDE 2



TITLE:             IMPLICATIONS OF OROP



·        UNIFORM PENSION TO BE PAID TO THE ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL RETIRING IN THE SAME RANK WITH SAME LENGTH OF SERVICE IRRESPECTIVE OF DATE OF RETIREMENT



·        ANY FUTURE ENHANCEMENT IN RATES OF PENSION BE AUTOMATICALLY PASSED ON TO THE PAST PENSIONERS 



SLIDE 3



TITLE:             RECOMMENDATIONS ON OROP



·        HISTORY OF RECOMMENDATIONS


·        CURRENT STATUS


Ø     IMPROVEMENT OF PENSIONARY BENEFITS OF JCOs/OR


Ø     GOVT HAS ATTEMPTED TO BRIDGE THE GAP FOR JCOs/ORS


Ø     ATTEMPT TO BRIDGE GAP FOR OFFICERS LIMITED TO LT GENs ONLY


Ø     DIFFERENCE IN PERCEPTIONS EXIST – BANE OF THE PROBLEM



SLIDE 4



TITLE:             IMPORTANT PRONOUNCEMENTS



·        PRE 10.10.1997 JCO/OR PENSIONERS BROUGHT AT PAR WITH 10.10.1997 PENSIONERS


·        ENHANCED RATE OF CLASSIFICATION ALLOWANCE FOR PENSION


·        PENSION OF ALL 01.01.2006 JCOs AND ORs BROUGHT AT PAR WITH POST 01.01.2006 RETIREES


·        SEPARATE PAY SCALES OF Rs 67000-79000 CREATED TO ADDRESS ISSUE OF DISPARITY IN PRE AND POST 01.01.2006 PENSIONERS OF LT GEN RANK


·        BENEFIT OF BROAD BANDING OF DISABILITY/WAR INJURY PENSION PARTIALLY RESOLVED


·        BRIG K P SINGH DEO (RETD) COMMITTEE REPORT 1983




SLIDE 5         



TITLE:                         EXAMPLES



·        DIFFERENCE IN PENSION BETWEEN LT COL AND MAJ GEN   Rs 1000/-


·        DIFFERENCE IN PENSION BETWEEN COL AND BRIG      Rs 100/-


·        DIFFERENCE IN PENSION BETWEEN MAJ AND LT COL  Rs 11600/-


·        WIDE DIFFERENCE IN PENSION OR PRE AND POST 2006 FAMILY OF PENSIONERS


·        DIFFERENCE IN PENSION BETWEEN PRE AND POST 2006 ORs


·        PRE-2006 HAV PENSIONERS GET LOWER PENSION THAN A POST 1.1.2006 SEPOY


·        PRE-2006 MAJ GEN PENSIONER GETS LOWER PENSION THAN POST 1.1.2006 LT COL




SLIDE 6         



TITLE:               ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS



·        ABSOLUTE FIGURES AFTER GOVT IMPROVEMENTS


o       JCOs/Ors


o       OFFICERS


·        APPARENT REASONS FOR DIFFERENCES


o       PAY SCALES TO RUNNING PAY BANDS AND FITMENT TABLES TO BOTTOM OF THE BAND


o       EXCLUSION OF NEW SCHEMES e.g. ACP TO PAST RETIREE PENSION CALCULATIONS – CONCERTINA EFFECT



SLIDE 7         



TITLE:                         WAY OUT



SOLUTION RECOMMENDED WILL SATISFY 90% OF EX-SERVICEMEN (SUPPORTED BY RECENT JUDGMENTS)



·        PRE 01 JAN 06 RETIREES BROUGHT AT PAR WITH POST 01 JAN 06 RETIREES (EVERY PAY COMMISSION)


·        RUNNING PAY BAND PROBLEM TO BE RESOLVED AS UNDER: -


o       OFFICERS: FIX A BENCH MARK WITHIN THE RUNNING PAY BAND FOR EACH RANK BASED ON MINIMUM SERVICE FOR EACH RANK e.g


§        LT COL (13 YEARS) – BOTTOM OF PB-4+GP+NEW PAY AND ALL CES


§        COL (15 YEARS) – AS ABOVE + 2 INCREMENTS


§        COL (TS) – 26 YEARS – AS ABOVE +3 INCREMENTS



·        JCOs/ORs: AS HAS BEEN DONE + BENEFIT OF ACP AND NEW PAY AND ALLOWANCE


·        NEW ALLOWANCES BENEFIT CARRY NO ARREARS


·        SIMILAR EXERCISE TO BE CARRIED OUT FOR PRE-2006 FAMILY PENSIONERS (ALL TYPES)


·        RE-FIXATION AT EVERY FIVE YEARS TO REDUCE GAP


·        RESTORATION OF WEIGHTAGES FOR PENSION


·        EXTENSION OF NON-FUNCTIONAL UPGRADATION AS IN CASE OF CIVIL CADRES  



SLIDE 8



TITLE:             PENSION OF JCOs AND ORs



RANK
PRE 01 JAN 2006 (ORIGINAL VI CPC)
Revised Pre 01 Jan 2006 (Revised by Govt)
Post 01 Jan 2006

X Gp
Y Gp
X Gp
Y Gp
X Gp
Y Gp
Sep
(19 yrs)
4679
4348
6227
5330
8025
7045
Nk
(24 yrs)
5175
4908
6900
6046
8200
7245
Hav
(26 yrs)
6062
5496
7905
6783
9410
8220
Nb Sub
(28 yrs)
8450
7750
11510
10675
11510
10675
Sub
(30 yrs)
11066
10532
13105
11970
13105
11970
Sub Maj
11350
10793
13450
12285
13590
12285



PENSION OF OFFICERS
Rank
Pre 01 Jan 2006
Post 01 Jan 2006
Maj
14100
22135
Lt Col
25700
28695
Col
26050
30375
Brig
26150
31170
Maj Gen
26700
33925
Lt Gen
36500
39500



SLIDE 9



TITLE:             MAJ RECOMMENDATIONS OF SHRI K P SINGH DEO COMMITTEE



·        RESTORATION OF PENSION AS EXISTED PRIOR TO III CPC – LITERALLY OROP EXISTED


·        RANK PLAYED A VERY IMPORTANT ROLE IN MILITARY. REFLECTED ITS ETHOS AND IS ALLOWED TO BE RETAINED AS PER OUR CONSTITUTION. EVEN AFTER RETIREMENT, PENSIONS SHOULD BE RANK BASED


·        EVERY SUBSTANTIVE OFFICER, JCO AND OTHERS SHOULD RECEIVED THE PENSION OF RANK HELD ON RETIREMENT IRRESPECTIVE OF THEIR VINTAGE AND DATE OF RETIREMENT.



Note:- Pi charts on proportion of ranks vis-à-vis civilians etc under preparation as author is not fluent in PowerPoint.  

Contention points/statements highlighted in Red  
*                 *                 *                   *                   *

No comments:

Post a Comment